Mar 182012

Winterkatze did a meme-like thing a while back, and I thought it might be fun to play along. It’s an 8-things-to-1-topic-thing. And the topic is “book or audio book”. Now, I almost wrote audiobook or real book here, just so you know.

  1. I didn’t really know this about myself but I seem to not like being read to. I remember when I met my husband and I had these lovely visions of us reading passages of our favorite books to each other. Then he said he doesn’t like being read to. I was miffed. Then I found that I don’t like being read to as well.
  2. It seems that when I only hear something it immediately starts to slip my mind. Like a 3-year-old. Tell me to do this and that, and chances are I forget at least one of them.
  3. When I first found out about audiobooks I loved the idea. A friend of mine had just recorded her first novel as an audio book, and I put it on my iPod, and thought how brilliant it was to be able to knit and ‘read’ at the same time.
  4. Then I started listening. And found that my mind started wandering. All of a sudden I had missed a whole paragraph. And then another one. And then I tried listening really hard. And then it happened again. And again. It doesn’t have anything to do with that particular book, I tried several others as well but I could never follow, I had to wind back too often.
  5. While my attention often wanders, and I find that I’ve missed a passage in an audio book, at the same time they go way too slow. I kept listening, and thinking, “If this were a real, printed book I would have been two pages further by now.
  6. I also don’t like the fact that audio books are often abbreviated. I think it’s been getting better with MP3s, but I distinctly remember the very first audiobook I got. The very same Winterkatze gave me a copy of “The Fifth Elephant” by Terry Pratchett as a German audiobook. She said the narrator was really good, and that she loved the book. Now, I had read “The Fifth Elephant”, of course, because Pratchett is one of the authors I buy every single book from. In hardcover. As soon as it’s out. So I started listening to the audiobook – then still on CDs – while puttering around the room. Well. I didn’t like the fact that it was in German. I didn’t like the narrator. He was doing funny voices. I don’t like funny voices when being read to. I didn’t like the translated names. But all of that is not really the fault of the audiobook. Or Winterkatze, nope, not at all. And then there came this passage. And I realized that something that I had liked tremendously in the book had been cut out. That was when I stopped listening to that particular audiobook.
  7. I didn’t give up on audiobooks right then. Nope. I got myself a trial Audible-membership, and downloaded two more I think. I got something by the Dalai Lama on happiness which I’m slowly winding my way through, over the years. I also got “Getting Unstuck” by Pema Chodron, and two of the Yarn Harlot’s books, “At Knit’s End”, and “Stephanie Pearl McPhee casts off”. Plus a German book from the library. The happiness one and the German one were quite hard to listen to. The German one was abbreviated again, so it didn’t take quite as long. I still haven’t finished the happiness book even though I’ve had it for years and years.
  8. The audiobooks I like best are the ones that are either lectures, like the “Getting Unstuck” one, or shorter, humorous essays like the Yarn Harlot ones. So the nearer an audiobook is to actual speech the better I can understand it. I have no problems at all listening to podcasts, by the way, only audiobooks. Also radio plays work better for me as well.
  9. Trying to get used to audiobooks made me also realize that I often hop back and forth on the page when reading a ‘normal’ book. When I’m reading something I don’t find as interesting, I skip ahead, look how long it will be, and then go back to reading again. Also I’m a really fast reader. At my normal reading speed I just zoom along. Whoosh, and the book is done. Not so much with the audiobooks.

So, what about you? Book or audiobook, or both? I’m curious.

  2 Responses to “book or audiobook?”

  1. I’ve been practicing, hopefully improving, my limited German by subscribing to a couple of blogs, trying out my German reading skills, then clipping and pasting the new posts so that Google Translate can backstop me.
    This morning I discovered (tell me it’s a brand new feature, and that I haven’t just failed to see it!) that Google can also read the entry read out loud to me. And–good grief–even vary the reading speed.
    I read very quickly in English, and haven’t the patience for listening to somebody else read an audiobook to me.
    But German blog entries! These I will be reading, and listening to.

  2. Oh, ich hatte ganz vergessen, dass ich dir den fünften Elefanten gegeben hatte – das ist aber schon sehr lange her! *g*

    Mein Mann und ich haben uns in den ersten Jahren, die wir zusammen waren, wirklich gegenseitig Bücher vorgelesen. Allerdings in der Regel Jugendbücher und da ist das Folgen auch möglich, wenn zwischendurch die Aufmerksamkeit abschweift. 😉 Und wir haben diese gemeinsame Zeit mit einer Geschichte wirklich genossen!

    Sachbücher liegen mir als Audiobooks nicht so sehr, denn bei denen springe ich gern im Text hin und her. Aber ein guter Sprecher, eine fesselnde oder sonst reizvolle Geschichte und ich genieße es mir vorlesen zu lassen! Und ich mag es, dass ich gleichzeitig die Hände frei habe zum Handarbeiten. 🙂 Und auch Hörspiele sind mein Ding, aber das war es schon als Kind, wenn ich Märchen-Schallplatten zum Einschlafen gehört habe.

    Die “richtigen” Bücher werden die Hörbücher nie ersetzen können, aber als Ergänzung möchte ich auf Hörbücher nicht verzichten. 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.